The importance of single-line diagrams for arc flash studies

The blueprint and start of an arc flash study


February 27, 2024

By: Ben Gibb, P.Eng., PE

Let's talk about the single-line diagram: a tool creating a safer environment when dealing with arc flash risks and hazards.

Understanding the importance of single-line diagrams in arc flash studies doesn't require expert knowledge, only a basic understanding of power systems. We'll explore what single-line diagrams are, how they function within the context of arc flash studies, and why they're fundamental in electrical safety.

It's helpful to understand what an arc flash is. It stems from an arc fault and is separate from an arc blast. The arc flash is a rapid release of heat caused between conductors or ground. Such faults can result in high energy and serious harm to people and damage to equipment, leading to costly downtimes.

When it comes to studying and mitigating these occurrences, single-line diagrams play an essential role. A single-line diagram or one-line diagram is an electrical drawing that uses individual lines and graphic symbols to represent the flow of electrical power in a system.

In Canada, CSA Z462, IEEE standards such as 141, and CEC 2021 mandate the maintenance of an updated, legible single-line diagram for electrical systems. This diagram gives a comprehensive view of the involved equipment and the interconnections among them. Additionally, such a diagram is advantageous in planning the power system, analyzing faults, and designing protection mechanisms.

Imagine if you're trying to solve a jigsaw puzzle but you don't have the finished picture to guide you. How much harder would assembling the pieces be? The same goes with arc flash studies. Without a single-line diagram, it's like navigating blind in calculating the potential incident energy and determining the arc flash hazards.

The single-line diagram consists of a multitude of detailed elements such as:

  • Utility supply system: ampacity of bus, continuous-current rating, maximum and minimum short-circuit duty, etc.
  • Transformers: Ratings, voltage taps, temperature rise, grounding scheme, etc.
  • Switchgear: Manufacturer details, type, model, current rating, operational mode, symmetrical interrupting current rating, etc.
  • Capacitor banks: Location, rating, connections, and switching configuration

In an arc flash study, these details from a single-line diagram are used to create an impedance matrix — something that drives the end-result arc flash energy calculations. The SLD also helps to identify potential hazards, determine lock-out points, calculate arc flash boundaries, and establish proper protective gear and equipment for personnel at various locations in the facility.

Since the single-line diagram indicates all possible sources of voltage under normal and emergency conditions, it provides a clear view of energy flow within the system. It also helps identify isolation points, interlocks, and switching arrangements, which are essential during emergencies.

Software can be used to dynamically maintain these diagrams as the site changes over time. The software is often linked to protective device coordination and arc flash hazard analysis tools. This integration allows for prompt updates when equipment or system changes occur, ensuring the diagram remains accurate.

In conclusion, a single-line diagram serves as the roadmap and starting point for conducting an effective arc flash study. It provides visual confirmation of the complexity of the electrical system, marks potential arc flash hazards, and plays an integral role in determining incident energy levels at varying locations. Maintaining an up-to-date diagram ensures that measures can be taken to optimize worker safety and system protection.